The leading publisher of teaching resources and ready to use material for the education of gifted children, gifted students and advanced learners. Prufrock Press Inc. 800.998.2208

Prufrock's Gifted Education Blog

About The Author  
Joel McIntosh
Joel McIntosh
I'm the publisher at Prufrock Press. I've been involved with gifted education for more than 20 years and hold a masters degree in gifted education. I've been a classroom teacher and a parent (still am that). In addition to this blog, you can visit me on Facebook or on Linkedin. I also publish a personal Web site which features pictures of my friends and family. Feel free to contact me by e-mail if you have any questions about this blog or Prufrock Press, Inc.

Current Articles | Categories | Search | Syndication

Gifted Children Especially Vulnerable to Effects of Bullying

Saturday, April 22, 2006 - by JMcIntosh - 1420 Views - 4 Comments - Category: Gifted and Talented Children
Gifted Children are Vulnerable to the Effects of BullyingThis morning I came across an article from the Purdue University News Service. The article was titled "Gifted Children Especially Vulnerable to Effects of Bullying," and it summarized research findings coming from a study by Dr. Jean S. Peterson and Ms. Karen E. Ray at Purdue University.

Quoting from the article:
    In what is believed to be the first major study of bullying and gifted students, researchers found that by eighth grade, more than two-thirds of gifted students had been victims.

    "All children are affected adversely by bullying, but gifted children differ from other children in significant ways," says Jean Sunde Peterson, an associate professor of educational studies in Purdue's College of Education.

    "Many are intense, sensitive, and stressed by their own and others' high expectations, and their ability, interests, and behavior may make them vulnerable. Additionally, social justice issues are very important to them, and they struggle to make sense of cruelty and aggression. Perfectionists may become even more self-critical, trying to avoid mistakes that might draw attention to themselves."
It does strike me that gifted children might find the effects of bullying especially difficult to manage. It is generally accepted that gifted children often have heightened emotional sensitivities. It makes a lot of sense that, in turn, gifted children respond more strongly to something as unfair and cruel as bullying.

In the article, Dr. Peterson offers some suggestions for parents concerned about this issue. "We found that the vast majority of students who were bullied were silent about it because they thought others would see them as weak or because they believed they wouldn't be taken seriously. That's why it's crucial that adults take an interest in their child's life and pay attention if they mention they're being picked on."

Dr. Peterson explains that if a parent suspects their child is being bullied, the first step is to talk with school officials. "Most bullying probably happens under the radar, and teachers may not be aware of it. It is important that all school personnel agree that bullying can be either or both verbal and physical, and it needs to be addressed in and outside of the classroom whenever it occurs."

The findings of this study will be published in two separate articles scheduled to appear in the Spring 2006 and Summer 2006 issues of Gifted Child Quarterly.

Resources About Bulling and What to Do About It

I'm not terribly well versed in this subject, and I don't publish any books on the topic. However, I respect the folks over at Free Spirit Publishing, and they have published several books on this topic. The reviews for their books on this issue are very positive.

Teachers concerned about bullying in their classroom and school may wish to take a look at The Bully Free Classroom: Over 100 Tips and Strategies for Teachers K-8.

Free Spirit also publishes a book for kids on this subject titled, Bullies are a Pain in the Brain. This book looks like a really good resource for kids during the elementary years.

Feel free to suggest other resources or insights on this topic using the "Add Comment" button below.
Comments
By Marcie Booth @ Thursday, May 10, 2007 12:56 PM
Do you have any information on the bullying of students by teachers? Our two boys are both identified as gifted and attend a public magnet school for gifted children. In spite of being highly trained in gifted education, some of the teachers seem to not understand the social-emotional needs of this clustered student population. I have seen some of the teachers get very angry and critical of the children when they make a mistake which is very typical of their age group, like forgetting their homework. Some of the parents have gone to the principal for help but she is very defensive of "her" teachers and is very la-ze faire when it comes to intervening on behaf of the children. We don't want to remove our kids from the school. What else can parents do to support the children and help change the environment in some of the classrooms? We believe that gifted educators should also be trained in understanding the psychological and social-emotional needs of these special kids. Thank-you.
By Valentine Cawley @ Thursday, May 10, 2007 12:56 PM
Dear Marcie,

In my blog you will find a successful case study of just the situation you are describing. One of my readers had a problem with a teacher bullying her gifted child. I advised a change of class: the change has been a great success. Don't sit and endure the bullying of your child: move your boys to a situation in which they are welcome.

The post in which the successful outcome is described is called: "Are you the parent of a gifted child?" The post in which she raises the serious behavioural problem of her son's teacher is under "A confederacy of dunces." I hope they help you by providing an example of how to proceed - and how successful it can be.

Best wishes.
By Leanne Manniche @ Thursday, May 10, 2007 12:57 PM
We had a 'year from hell' last year (2005) with our child at his school where his behaviour was eventually resulting in suspensions! We, mind you had no such incidences at home.
We had professionals examine him and consult with us, to find, that in our final effort to resolve the situation, he was moved to a different grade and up a year level to experience a wonderful, trouble free final term of the year!
We didn't realise the extent of the impact that this (what I now
term 'negligent')teachers actions made on our son until just recently when she returned to a school presentation and our son was cowering behind me to avoid her!!! No child should fear someone this much. Step in and demand, but demand with knowledge and resources to back you up. Parents ultimately have the say in their child's educational process and it is something we have found that requires constant vigilance.
Just for reference, this year he has a young teacher who has had no problems what so ever.
By Nanci @ Thursday, February 21, 2008 1:14 PM
I just found your site. This week I switched my 10 year old, 5th grade son from public to private school because he had spent the past 6 years dealing with bullies. He's in all of the advanced learning programs the school offers and is continuously taunted by both students and teachers because of this. This past month the school principal started contributing. I believe it may have been due in part to me involving the school superintendant because nothing has ever been done to discourage the bullies. All they've ever done is check to see if my son was getting help, was he getting counseling, etc. In my opinion it doesn't do a darn bit of good to get him help if he's going to continue going back into an environment where he's going to get belittled, degraded and pushed around (he's the shortest boy for at least three grades lower than his) by boys, girls, teachers and now the principal. The first day of school at his new school he was elated by the fact he already had friends when he went home. (Thank you God!) but since the school is privately funded they don't have advanced programs like the public schools did. I don't want him to slow down academically. I believe that now that he no longer has the bullies to worry about he will excel even more than he had been; but I'm not able to find any local groups or programs. If I have to do it myself, I will. I just need to know what to do. Can you help me?
You must be logged in to post a comment. You can login here
Search Button  

 
Search Entries

Your Account  
News Feed  

CNN Education News

e-mail: info@prufrock.com   phone:800.998.2208   international phone:1.254.756.3337   ©2006 Prufrock Press. All Rights Reserved.

Prufrock Press Inc. publishes books, textbooks, teaching aids, journals, and magazines supporting gifted education and gifted children.