The leading publisher of teaching resources and ready to use material for the education of gifted children, gifted students and advanced learners. Prufrock Press Inc. 800.998.2208

Prufrock's Gifted Education Blog

About The Author  
Joel McIntosh

Joel McIntosh
I'm the publisher at Prufrock Press. I've been involved with gifted education for more than 20 years and hold a masters degree in gifted education. I've been a classroom teacher and a parent (still am that). Most of the entries here are mine, but, from time to time, I invite Prufrock Press' authors to write a guest blog entry. Feel free to contact me by e-mail.

Current Articles | Categories | Search | Syndication

Articles from April 2005

Teaching the Test, Not Gifted Children

Tuesday, April 26, 2005 - by JMcIntosh - 412 Views - 0 Comments - Category: Gifted Education
Teaching the Test, Not Gifted Children

Recently, the Texas legislature passed a law that allows districts to give 2 weeks off to any student who passes the state's mandated accountability tests. Even worse, HB 524, currently before the legislature, would allow school districts to only require 4 days of school per week for “certain high-performing students." I mention this here because Texas often acts as a barometer for the educational mood of the rest of the country, and I think this particular mood is not a positive one for gifted education.

According to this kind of legislation, if your children can pass the state's skills test, we don't even pretend that public school holds any educational value for them. They can just go home. Getting rid of the gifted kids gives "teachers more one-on-one with the students who are not passing," Suzanne Marchman, a Texas Education Agency spokeswoman, explained in the Dallas Morning News. Clearly, we here in Texas are just focused on making sure everyone passes the tests, and we don't have time to bother with students who already can.

This kind of legislation is the direct result of the half-cocked "No Child Left Behind" initiative. The problem with No Child Left Behind is that it's wrong-headed. Anita Sharpe, in her blog, asks if the initiative wouldn't be better named "No Child Should Get Too Far Ahead," and I think she's right. Here's the basic idea behind "No Child Left behind" in the form of a sports metaphor. Your child's baseball coach announces that, from now on, every practice will be designed to ensure that every child on the team can pass a mandated minimum baseball-skills test. Those children able to exhibit mastery of the basic skills can go home because there is simply no time to coach anything beyond the basics. If you feel your child has baseball skills beyond the required minimum, perhaps you should enroll him or her in a special summer program because "we here in this baseball program are not interested in teaching all those new-fangled skills needed to actually win a baseball game."

I'm just tired of this. Those of us in gifted education have been running from this fight for too long. We watch as gifted programs get dismantled. We stand by as gifted children are placed back into regular education classrooms where they are forced to drill and practice for state achievement tests that they can already pass. We watch as thousands of parents pull their gifted kids out of public schools and place them in private schools and homeschools. We stand back as state universities eliminate teacher-training programs in gifted education. And I, for one, am tired of it.

I think it's about time that we as parents and teachers of gifted children get outraged at what's going on; time that we start raising hell with administrators who want to eliminate gifted programs in our schools; and time we start supporting those teachers out there who are going the extra mile for children of advanced ability.

And that's not enough. We've got to take an active role with legislators who don't support advanced academics. Through letters, phone calls, or votes, let those politicians who vote for legislation like that just passed in Texas know that we've had enough.

You've heard it before from shortsighted administrators, "Parents of gifted children are pushy." Well, let's start living up to our reputation and push with all we've got.

Getting Your Classroom Ideas Published

Tuesday, April 19, 2005 - by JMcIntosh - 357 Views - 0 Comments - Category: Fun and Interesting Stuff
For the last few years at the Texas Association for the Gifted and Talented's annual conference, I've been asked to do a presentation on how teachers of gifted kids can get their great ideas published. I like giving the presentation because everyone who comes to the session is excited about the topic. In this blog, I'll try to mention a few of the most important tips for getting published that I've shared in those presentations.

I can't speak for other publishing companies (but if I could, I would say "We are evil, and you should only buy from Prufrock Press!"), so the tips below are specific to how I like to work with authors.

When considering which companies to approach with your project, pick publishing companies that focus on the kind of material and topics you wish to develop. Most publishers have a niche in which they specialize. It does no good to submit even the best book idea on a topic to a publisher that doesn't publish books on that topic. I can't tell you how many proposals I get for topics such as "psychic phenomena explained," "nature poetry," and "phonics for young readers." Prufrock publishes exclusively for teachers and parents of gifted children and high-ability learners. We really can't consider proposals that are off-topic.

Once you've identified a handful of publishers that might be interested in your work, visit their Web site and see if they have online author support and guidance. If they don't, you can send them an SASE with a request for their author submission guidelines. At Prufrock, we have an area of our Web site devoted to helping authors get started. Of most benefit to a new author in this area are two downloadable documents. The first, "Topics and Areas for Acquisition," outlines the topics we're interested in having authors write about. The document gives you a general idea of the kinds of products we see ourselves publishing in the near future. The second is our "Book Prospectus Preparation Guidelines. These guidelines tell exactly what information should be included in a prospectus sent to us. It is so helpful for our editors when we receive a prospectus that conforms to these guidelines.

Prepare your prospectus with the marketplace in mind. Try to find the intersection of the topic you want to write about and what educators are buying. Here is a suggestion: Review the online catalog of the publisher to which you plan to submit your prospectus. Check out the publisher's bestsellers -- that's a good indication of what the education market is looking for.

Once you have a marketable education product in mind and a publisher's prospectus guidelines in hand, you can develop your proposal. Now, write your proposal and send it in. So many teachers talk to me about writing an activity book over the summer, but they never get around to sending in a prospectus. Take the leap, prepare you prospectus, and sent it in.

I wish you the best in getting published. If you have any questions or comments, please feel free to post them.

A Free Thinking Skills Puzzle for Gifted Kids

Sunday, April 17, 2005 - by JMcIntosh - 591 Views - 0 Comments - Category: Fun and Interesting Stuff

Super Smart by Stephen S. Young

Okay, here is a cool thinking skills puzzle you can do with your gifted students. The thinking skills puzzle below comes from this book (you can't order the book yet; we're still editing it and laying it out -- I'll let you know when it's available for preorders). Anyway, try this with your kids this week -- it's a good "hook" (what the author calls his thinking challenges) to get a classroom thinking.

Hook: You have two identical beakers, each holding an identical amount of fluid. One beaker holds red fluid, the other blue fluid. You take 1 tablespoon of the red fluid, drop it into the blue fluid and mix it up thoroughly. You then take 1 tablespoon of this mixture, drop it back into the red fluid and mix it up thoroughly. Question: Do you now have more red fluid in the predominantly blue beaker, more blue fluid in the predominantly red beaker, or are there equal amounts in each?

 

Solution: Equal amounts. Although the quantity in each beaker is irrelevant, let us assume, that, to begin with, each beaker has 9 tablespoons of fluid. In step one we transfer 1 tablespoon of red fluid to the blue beaker. We now have 10 tablespoons of fluid in that beaker, one-tenth of which is red and nine-tenths of which is blue. We now transfer 1 tablespoon of that mixture back into the red beaker. That tablespoon is one-tenth red and nine-tenths blue, so we have actually transferred one-tenth of a tablespoon of red fluid back intothe red container, making the net amount of red fluid left in the blue container nine-tenths of a tablespoon. When we transferred the mixture into the red container, that tablespoon was one-tenth red and nine-tenths blue, so the net amount of blue we transferred into the red container was also ninetenths of a tablespoon. Not as easy as it seemed at first, eh?

Visit Prufrock Press' online catalog to see our entire selection of thinking skills activity books.

Gifted Children ... Moldable and Manageable?

Saturday, April 16, 2005 - by JMcIntosh - 328 Views - 0 Comments - Category: Teaching Gifted Children
A few months back, I came across a blog entry that really got my blood boiling. The author managed to come to the conclusion that gifted kids are not gifted, just lucky ... "Lucky because they have parents who have the road smarts to know what it takes to make a child appear teachable, moldable. Rule and routine-oriented kids. Precocious kids. Charming kids. Easily manageable kids."

What!?! Gifted kids ... easily moldable and manageable? Anyone with the least bit of experience with gifted and talented students knows that they can be some of the most obstinate, hardheaded, and challenging kids in a classroom. A quick read of Carol Fertig's list of positive and challenging characteristics of gifted kids makes it pretty clear that any teacher or parent of gifted kids will need to keep on his or her toes to keep ahead of these children.

The blog's author was responding to a list of characteristics of gifted children and definitions of giftedness. I don't think anyone could read those definitions and come to the conclusion she did. I honestly think she ignored those definitions and just responded to the "label" of gifted. I don't know what we do with all of the prejudice surrounding this label, but it's irritating to see it so clearly outlined in print.

On the other hand, I read a wonderful blog entry titled "Why is 'gifted' such a dirty word?", about this topic from the perspective of a homeschooling parent. In her blog, the author tackles the idea that "all children are gifted." She writes, "all children are gifts, all children are special, and they all have the potential to bring joy into this world if their unique qualities are nourished and celebrated. But not all children are 'gifted.' 'Gifted' refers specifically to talents and abilities outside of the norm. A gifted athlete is markedly different from an average one. We know them when we see them, and not all the training and love in the world will make an ordinary person into a gifted athlete. It would be nonsensical to claim that we are all gifted athletically, so why, when we are talking about intellectually gifted children, do we try to claim that all children are gifted?" She goes on to ask why we are so afraid to recognize that some children are, as she puts it, "smarter than your average bear," and she considers the consequences for kids if we don't make an effort to address the special intellectual and social needs of gifted kids. The author's blog, Yet Another Homeschool Blog!, is well written and creative. Drop by if you get a chance.

 
Search Entries

Your Account  
News Feed  

CNN Education News

e-mail: info@prufrock.com   phone:800.998.2208   international phone:1.254.756.3337   ©2006 Prufrock Press. All Rights Reserved.

Prufrock Press Inc. publishes books, textbooks, teaching aids, journals, and magazines supporting gifted education and gifted children.