The leading publisher of teaching resources and ready to use material for the education of gifted children, gifted students and advanced learners. Prufrock Press Inc. 800.998.2208
Our Blogs Have Moved. For new and updated posts, please visit Prufrock Press' new blog at:

Prufrock's Gifted Child Information Blog

About The Author  
Carol Fertig

Carol Fertig

I have been active in the education community for more than 40 years and involved in gifted education for more than 20 years. At various times, I have been a classroom teacher, gifted education teacher, consultant, writer, editor—you name it. I live in Colorado, but also spend a fair amount of time in Chicago. I have two grown boys: one in Colorado and one in California. In my spare time, I enjoy skiing, mountain biking, and golfing. I also like to read, go to plays, and watch foreign movies. Feel free to send me an e-mail.

I am also the author of Raising a Gifted Child: A Parenting Success Handbook. This book offers a large menu of strategies, resources, organizations, tips, and suggestions for parents to find optimal learning opportunities for their gifted kids, covering the gamut of talent areas, including academics, the arts, technology, creativity, music, and thinking skills.

Raising a Gifted Child

Current Articles | Categories | Search | Syndication

Are Gifted Children Born or Made?

Friday, April 22, 2005 - by CFertig - Category: Parents and Educators
How much influence do we have over the development of the abilities of our children? To what extent can we attribute giftedness to natural-born ability, exposure, encouragement, socio-economic status, or ethnicity? What would have happened to the first violinist if she had never been exposed to an instrument? What would have happened to the professional golfer if he had never been exposed to the game? Would that talent manifest itself in some other form or would it be lost forever?
Because a young person shows a strong ability, does that mean she will always retain that ability? When a young person seems quite average, does that mean that no real strength will ever surface? We say that we want to give students the chance to realize their full potential. What does that mean?
It seems to me that there are more questions than answers.
When my youngest son was three, my mother sent us the piano I had played while growing up. Todd immediately took an interest in it and asked me to teach him how to play. I told him he was too young and to wait a few years. “No, Mommy, no. I promise I’ll practice. I want you to teach me how to play.” He begged and he begged and finally I began teaching him. Once he started, there was no stopping him. He couldn’t seem to walk past the piano without sitting down to play. If he didn’t play a piece perfectly, he would try and try again. As he struggled with this, he would sit at the piano bench, close his eyes, and draw his hand down over his face over and over again, convinced that this would stop the tears from coming—that he wouldn’t make a mistake the next time. I worried about him. He seemed to be such a perfectionist. Todd got his first real piano teacher at age five and just kept practicing. He used to be afraid to go on vacation because there might not be a piano available. Through the years, I never asked him to practice. I never needed to because he loved the piano so much. When it was time for college, he chose to be a piano major. I often wondered how his life would have been different had my mother never shipped that piano to us.
When my oldest son was in third grade we got our first Apple IIe computer. He was not the least bit interested in reading any books about computers or attending any computer classes. Somehow or another, though, he figured out how to break into the listings of programs to see the language the programmer had entered. And somehow he figured out what parts of the listing caused which functions in the program. Then he memorized what he learned and put the parts together in new ways to create his own programs. Sometimes he would sit at the computer doing this for an entire day. I questioned my ability as a parent. Should I have limited the time he was allowed to sit in front of the computer screen? Now, as an adult, he builds and maintains computer systems for companies. I often wonder how his life would have been different if we hadn’t purchased that first Apple IIe.
In his article Small Wonders—Prodigies: So Bright , Andrew Marshall explores child prodigies and ponders whether they are born or made.
Whether we are talking about prodigies or gifted students, many of the same questions arise. Are these students born or made? What correlation is there between the performance of the student and his parents’ socio/economic status? What role does exposure play? Are very bright students gifted by accident or are they just mentally more efficient? Can the management of mental resources be developed? Scientists aren’t sure.
In Child Prodigies, by Joanna Schaffhausen, the author reports that being born with a high IQ or amazing piano ability is no guarantee of later success, and parents who push too hard are likely to set their child up for a fall. Some very bright students have a difficult time when other children manage to "catch up" by high school.
On the other hand, parents of seemingly "ordinary" children should not despair; many of the world's most significant contributions have been made by people who struggled as youngsters. Mozart was a child prodigy; Beethoven was not. The world still marvels at them both.
If this is a subject that is of interest to you, check out the lists of books on the website for The Hollingworth Center for Highly Gifted Children.
Search Button  

Search Entries

Education News  

Education News on CNN

e-mail:   phone:800.998.2208   international phone:1.254.756.3337   ©2008 Prufrock Press. All Rights Reserved.

Prufrock Press Inc. publishes books, textbooks, teaching aids, journals, and magazines supporting gifted education and gifted children.